Why has Canada NOT legalized Marijuana?

It is almost impossible to find a valid argument for our laws prohibiting marijuana use. While it may not be the healthiest substance on the face of the earth, there is no evidence that it is nearly as harmful as tobacco or alcohol, which are not only legal but a major source of income for the government, via taxes.

Our freedom of choice is seriously hampered by the law that makes marijuana possession a criminal offense. The drug does not kill. Users pose no threat to society. Unlike many who consume alcohol to excess, marijuana users do not get violent or aggressive when they smoke too much. They are more likely to fall asleep. Unlike tobacco and alcohol, marijuana is not addictive. It may have a negative impact on motivation and short term memory – but that’s hardly a valid reason for making possession, use or even cultivation a criminal offense. We allow people to legally engage in all sorts of activities known to be life-threatening, so why do we treat people who use a drug that harms absolutely no one, except – MAYBE – themselves, as criminals?

One of the most vehement arguments against legalizing marijuana is that it is a “gateway drug.”  If we smoke marijuana, some say, we are much more likely to start using other,  more dangerous and addictive drugs like ecstasy, LSD, cocaine and heroin.  The thousands of regular marijuana users in this country would, I think, strenuously argue the contrary. However, it is true that people who become addicted to more dangerous drugs often begin by experimenting with marijuana. Since marijuana is illegal, the only way to procure it (unless one has a medical reason for use) is through drug dealers. And yes, drug dealers often have more in their arsenals than just marijuana. So because marijuana is illegal, people who want to purchase it are exposed to criminals who may tempt them into trying other drugs. If it were legal, there would be no gateway issue. People could buy marijuana at controlled outlets and would not need to have any contact with dealers.

Right now the government spends money hunting down and incarcerating people who are harming no one. Even those who sell marijuana are not harming anyone; they are simply meeting a well-established need. The police waste time searching out grow-ops and picking up people who are high. The courts get jammed up with cases, our prisons overcrowded. It’s ludicrous.

If marijuana were legal, no one would suffer. It could be sold as a controlled substance, which might actually reduce the number of young people using the drug. The police and our courts could devote their energies to dealing with criminals who steal, abuse, terrorize or kill others. The government could tax marijuana and use the income to help Canadians.

Some would say that just because we have legalized other dangerous substances, that’s no reason to legalize another one that might be harmful. This argument has some merit, but only if we believe the government should make health and lifestyle choices for us. And if that is the case, the government should immediately ban tobacco and alcohol use, bungy-jumping, snowmobiling and a long list of other activities that are known to have risks. Otherwise we’re being hypocritical. Either the government should dictate what people are allowed to do in their own time or they should stay out of our personal business as long as our choices do not hurt others.  I very much hope that no one in this country wants the government interfering in our personal lives.

Given that Canadians pride themselves on championing individual rights and freedoms, it’s ridiculous that our government has not legalized marijuana.


4 thoughts on “Why has Canada NOT legalized Marijuana?

  1. Meg – I agree with the basic premise, but not with some of the arguments. I do think pot can be addictive, as can all mood-altering substances for some people, based on friends I had at various times who used pot in the same way as alcoholics drink. Speaking of which, I’m pretty sure the gateway drug is alcohol – I really doubt that very many people have smoked, or injected, before they drank, so banning pot as a gateway drug is silly. And I think the government should make some health and lifestyle choices for us – making drinking and driving illegal isn’t an infringement on my right to do so, but protection for those of us who have to drive. Similarly, it would be difficult to argue that the anti-smoking campaigns haven’t been effective, although notably without making cigarettes illegal. This raises the rather interesting question of when it is appropriate for society to limit freedom of choice, for the common good as opposed to the good of the individual – looking forward to your thoughts on that one…

  2. Well that is pretty much my point – I think that as long as an individual’s choices do not negatively impact others, society/the state should stay out (of homes as well as bedrooms.) The drinking and driving example is a good one – that law is designed to protect others, not the individual (although it may protect him/her as well) and that is as it should be. Banning smoking indoors and in public places also makes sense to me. But the fact that it’s illegal to smoke pot although legal to drink or participate in extreme sports does not seem right.
    I should have said marijuana is not physically addictive – no serious withdrawal symptoms, unlike alcohol or nicotine. I’m sure it is psychologically addictive, but people I know who are regular users do not become irritable/freak out if they stop for a period of time (e.g. when they are traveling.)
    And yes, alcohol may well be a gateway drug too – but since it is legal, people purchasing it do not have to deal with folks working outside the law – the same isn’t true of marijuana.
    Thanks for all the comments!

  3. For every one that want the legalization of it its times to vote in the next Canadian federal election (2015) for the Liberal party,

    Look what Justin Trudeau is saying at 5:39s of the following video;

    Also read theese both webpages

    117. Legalize and Regulate Marijuana


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s